P Tools

I Tried The Best Web Scraping Tools: What Actually Worked For Me

Written by

in

I’m Kayla. I scrape the web for work and for fun. Price checks. Event alerts. Little dashboards I share with my team. For turning all that scraped data into visuals, I lean on a few business intelligence tools that I’ve already vetted. I don’t scrape stuff I’m not allowed to. I read robots.txt. I follow site rules. That part matters.

Here’s the thing: tools feel the same from far away. But they don’t feel the same when you’re up at 6 a.m., fixing a broken spider before coffee. So I’ll tell you what I used, what broke, and what I’d use again. For the full breakdown, I logged my results in this best web scraping tools report.

My Quick Picks (Real-Life Use Cases)

  • Scrapy for serious projects (I tracked 500+ coffee roasters).
  • Playwright when pages need a real browser (infinite scroll, sticky JS).
  • BeautifulSoup + Requests for small jobs (simple tables, my blog cleanup).
  • Apify when I want a scheduled job in the cloud.
  • Octoparse for no-code, point-and-click scraping.
  • SerpAPI for search results, without wrestling raw Google HTML.
  • Zyte Smart Proxy or Bright Data when sites get picky and block fast.

You know what? I still keep Selenium around. But Playwright stole my heart.
For side-by-side specs of nearly every scraper I’ve mentioned, I also skim the living comparison table at ptools.org when I’m deciding which tool fits a new project. I also recommend a comprehensive comparison of web scraping tools that breaks down Scrapy, Playwright, BeautifulSoup, and more.

Why I Scrape (And What Kicked This Off)

I wanted a simple price tracker for coffee beans. Then I needed event times for a local venue. Later, my team asked for a sheet of brand mentions. This is how it goes. One small script turns into a workflow.

Let me explain how each tool fit.

Scrapy: My Weekend Price Tracker

I built a Scrapy project to track indie coffee roasters. About 520 shops. I pulled bean names, roast level, price per bag, and tasting notes. I used CSS selectors. I set AutoThrottle. I sent data to PostgreSQL with a pipeline. It ran all weekend and didn’t choke.

  • What I loved: Fast. Clean project structure. Exports to CSV or JSON with one command. The middleware is chef’s kiss.
  • What bugged me: The learning curve. Feels heavy for tiny tasks.
  • Real note: I paired it with Zyte Smart Proxy. Fewer blocks. Fewer 403s. Worth it for big runs.

Would I use Scrapy again? For anything bigger than 50 pages, yes.

Playwright (Python): When Pages Act Busy

One venue website used infinite scroll and lazy-loaded times. My Requests code got nothing. So I used Playwright. I waited for selectors, then scrolled. I even blocked images to go faster. I ran it headless on a small server and wrote results to a Google Sheet via a script.

  • What I loved: It feels like a real browser. The waits are sane. Debugging with a trace is great.
  • What bugged me: Heavier than simple scraping. Needs more compute.
  • Real note: I used it on my own logged-in account pages too, for my data. Be careful with terms, always.

When pages get weird, Playwright is my “fine, I’ll drive” tool.

While testing Playwright against age-gated dating portals, I noticed that some sites showcasing mature profiles rely heavily on JavaScript and endless scrolling. If you want a live example to poke around, check out FuckLocal’s MILFs page—browsing it will show you exactly how infinite scroll, modal gates, and dynamic content loading behave so you can plan smarter selectors and waits for your own scrapers.

Another pattern I study when refining selectors is the classic forum layout—dozens of text posts, quote boxes, and next-page links that can trip up naive pagination code. A solid sandbox for this is the USA Sex Guide Athens discussion where you can observe how a traditional bulletin board handles user replies and multi-page threads, giving you a realistic dataset to test everything from link extraction to sentiment parsing.

BeautifulSoup + Requests: The Trusty Butter Knife

I use this pair every week. It’s light. It’s fast. It’s boring in the best way.

  • I fixed broken links on my recipe blog. Pulled all internal links. Found 404s. Patched the list.

  • I scraped a farmer’s market schedule. Just one HTML table. Took ten minutes. Exported CSV. Done.

  • What I loved: Quick wins. Small script. Easy to read later.

  • What bugged me: Hates heavy JavaScript. That’s fair.

If the page is plain HTML, this is the move.

Apify: Set It and (Almost) Forget It

I used Apify to crawl a university department news page. I ran the Website Content Crawler nightly. It exported to a dataset I pulled into Sheets. It sent a Slack ping if the job failed. That saved me a few gray hairs.

  • What I loved: Schedules, logs, storage, webhooks. Feels like a tiny scraping studio.
  • What bugged me: Costs add up when runs grow. Watch your usage.

When I need a “run it every day at 4 a.m.” thing, I grab Apify.

Octoparse: Point, Click, Collect

A friend needed apartment listings in a spreadsheet. No-code was best for them. We trained Octoparse on the fields: title, price, beds, link. It handled pagination once we taught it the next button. We ran it in the cloud and got Excel files on schedule.

  • What I loved: Fast setup for non-coders. Nice preview.
  • What bugged me: Anti-bot walls hurt it. I had to tweak delays and steps.

If you don’t code, this will still get you data.

SerpAPI: Search Results Without The Mess

My team wanted brand mentions. Scraping search result HTML is a pain. I used SerpAPI instead. One call. Clean JSON. Title, link, snippet, even ads marked as ads. We filtered by time and country.

  • What I loved: It just works. Less brittle than parsing raw search pages.
  • What bugged me: You pay per request. But we saved time.

For search, I don’t roll my own anymore.

Proxies: Zyte Smart Proxy And Bright Data

When my Scrapy spider grew large, I hit blocks. I used Zyte Smart Proxy for rotation and retries. For one tough job, Bright Data residential IPs helped too. I used them only on sites that allow scraping and with gentle rates.

  • Tip: Start slow. Respect robots.txt. Cache pages when you can.
  • Money note: Proxies can cost more than you think. Track it.

Selenium: The Old Workhorse

I used Selenium for years. It’s fine. But Playwright feels smoother now. I still have Selenium scripts running for one legacy dashboard. If it ain’t broken, I let it live.

What Surprised Me Most

  • Getting data is easy. Keeping it clean is not.
  • The schema matters. Field names should make sense to humans.
  • Retries help. So do timeouts. So does a small sleep.
  • Storage sneaks up on you. CSV today, a database tomorrow.
  • Websites change. Your scraper breaks. That’s normal.

Honestly, scraping is half code, half care.

What I’d Pick Again, Fast

  • Big crawl with rules and storage: Scrapy (+ Zyte Smart Proxy).
  • Dynamic page with scroll or heavy JS: Playwright.
  • One-page, simple HTML: Requests + BeautifulSoup.
  • Daily runs and logs in the cloud: Apify.
  • No-code team task: Octoparse.
  • Search results at scale: SerpAPI.

If you’re not sure where to start, try BeautifulSoup on a simple page you own. Then step up as you need. For a current snapshot of what’s hot, check out this in-depth guide to the best web scraping tools for 2024 to see how the landscape is shifting.

A Small Word On Ethics

I check robots.txt. I read site terms. I don’t take data that asks me not to. I rate-limit. I add a contact email in my headers. I honor “no scraping” rules. That trust matters.

Final Take

Scraping isn’t magic. It’s a toolbox. Pick the light tool first. Use the heavy gear when the page fights back. And save your work, because you’ll fix it later.

If you asked me what to install today, I’d say: BeautifulSoup for tiny stuff, Playwright for tricky stuff, Scrapy when you mean business. The rest fills the gaps.

—Kayla Sox

Comments

Leave a Reply

More posts